Stingless bees, sometimes called stingless honey bees or simply meliponines, are a large group of bees (approximately 500 species), comprising the tribe Meliponini (or subtribe Meliponina according to other authors). They belong in the family Apidae, and are closely related to common honey bees, carpenter bees, orchid bees and bumblebees. The common name is slightly misleading as male bees and bees of other species, such as those in the family Andrenidae, cannot sting. Meliponines have stingers, but they are highly reduced and cannot be used for defense.
- 1 Range
- 2 Behavior
- 3 Stingless bees of Australia
- 4 Stingless bees of Brazil
- 5 Mayan stingless bees of Central America
- 6 Stingless bee species that produce honey
- 7 References
- 8 External links
Stingless bees can be found in most tropical or subtropical regions of the world, such as Australia, Africa, Southeast Asia, and tropical America. The majority of native eusocial bees of Central and South America are stingless bees, although only a few of them produce honey on a scale such that they are farmed by humans. They are also quite diverse in Africa, including Madagascar, and are farmed there also; meliponine honey is prized as a medicine in many African communities as well as in South America.
Being tropical, stingless bees are active all year round, although they are less active in cooler weather, with some species presenting diapause. Unlike other eusocial bees, they do not sting but will defend by biting if their nest is disturbed. In addition, a few (in the genus Oxytrigona) have mandibular secretions that cause painful blisters. Despite their lack of a sting, stingless bees, being eusocial, may have very large colonies made formidable by the number of defenders.
Stingless bees usually nest in hollow trunks, tree branches, underground cavities, or rock crevices but they have also been encountered in wall cavities, old rubbish bins, water meters, and storage drums. Many beekeepers keep the bees in their original log hive or transfer them to a wooden box, as this makes it easier to control the hive.
The bees store pollen and honey in large egg-shaped pots made of beeswax, typically mixed with various types of plant resin (sometimes called "propolis"). These pots are often arranged around a central set of horizontal brood combs, where the larval bees are housed. When the young worker bees emerge from their cells, they tend to remain inside the hive, performing different jobs. As workers age, they become guards or foragers. Unlike the larvae of honey bees, meliponine larvae are not fed directly. The pollen and nectar are placed in a cell, an egg is laid, and the cell is sealed until the adult bee emerges after pupation ("mass provisioning"). At any one time, hives can contain 300–80,000 workers, depending on species.
In a simplified sense, the sex of each bee depends on the number of chromosomes it receives. Female bees have two sets of chromosomes (diploid)—one set from the queen and another from one of the male bees or drones. Drones have only one set of chromosomes (haploid), and are the result of unfertilized eggs, though inbreeding can result in diploid drones.
Unlike true honey bees, whose female bees may become workers or queens strictly depending on what kind of food they receive as larvae (queens are fed royal jelly and workers are fed pollen), the caste system in meliponines is variable, and commonly based simply on the amount of pollen consumed; larger amounts of pollen yield queens in the genus Melipona. There is also a genetic component however, and as much as 25% (typically 5–14%) of the female brood may be queens. Queen cells in the former case can be distinguished from others by their larger size, as they are stocked with more pollen, but in the latter case the cells are identical to worker cells, and scattered among the worker brood. When the new queens emerge, they typically leave to mate, and most die. New nests are not established via swarms, but by a procession of workers who gradually construct a new nest at a secondary location. The nest is then joined by a newly mated queen, at which point many workers take up permanent residence and help the new queen raise her own workers. If a ruling queen is herself weak or dying, then a new queen can replace her. For Plebeia quadripunctata, although less than 1% of female worker cells produce dwarf queens, they comprise six out of seven queen bees, and one out of five proceed to head colonies of their own. They are reproductively active but less fecund than large queens.
Stingless bees of Australia
Of the 1,600 species of wild bees native to Australia, about 14 species are stingless. These species bear a variety of names, including Australian native honey bees, native bees, sugar-bag bees and sweat bees (because they will land on a sweaty person to drink in dry times/areas). All are small, black in colour, with hairy extended hind legs for carrying nectar and pollen; because of the latter they are sometimes mistaken for bumblebees. The various stingless species look quite similar, with the two most common species, Trigona carbonaria and Austroplebeia australis, displaying the greatest variation, as the latter is smaller and less active. Both of these inhabit the area around Brisbane.
As stingless bees are harmless to humans, they have become an increasingly attractive addition to the suburban backyard. Most meliponine beekeepers do not keep the bees for honey but rather for the pleasure of conserving a native species whose original habitat is declining due to human development. In return, the bees pollinate crops, garden flowers, and bushland during their search for nectar and pollen.
While a number of beekeepers fill a small niche market for bush honey, native meliponines only produce small amounts and the structure of their hives makes the honey difficult to extract. It is only in warm areas of Australia such as Queensland and northern New South Wales that the bees can produce more honey than they need for their own survival. Harvesting honey from a nest in a cooler area could weaken or even kill the nest.
In warm areas of Australia, these bees can be used for minor honey production. They may also be kept successfully in boxes in these areas. Special methods are being developed to harvest moderate amounts of honey from stingless bees in these areas without causing harm.
Like the European honey bee (Apis mellifera), which provides most of Australia's commercially produced honey, stingless bees have enlarged areas on their back legs for carrying pollen back to the hive. After a foraging expedition, these pollen baskets or corbiculae can be seen stuffed full of bright orange or yellow pollen. Stingless bees also collect nectar, which they store in an extension of their gut called a crop. Back at the hive, the bees ripen or dehydrate the nectar droplets by spinning them inside their mouthparts until honey is formed. Ripening concentrates the nectar and increases the sugar content, though it is not nearly as concentrated as the honey from true honey bees; it is much thinner in consistency, and more prone to spoiling.
Stingless bees store their aromatic honey in clusters of small resin pots near the extremities of the nest. For honey production, the bees need to be kept in a box specially designed to make the honey stores accessible without damaging the rest of the nest structure. Some recent box designs for honey production provide a separate compartment for the honey stores so that honey pots can be removed without spilling honey into other areas of the nest.
Unlike a hive of commercial honeybees, which can produce 75 kilograms of honey a year, a hive of Australian stingless bees produces less than one kilogram. Stingless bee honey has a distinctive "bush" taste—a mix of sweet and sour with a hint of fruit. The taste comes from plant resins—which the bees use to build their hives and honey pots—and varies at different times of year depending on the flowers and trees visited.
Australian farmers rely heavily on the introduced Western honey bee to pollinate their crops. However, for some crops native bees may be better pollinators. Stingless bees have been shown to be valuable pollinators of crops such as macadamias and mangoes. They may also benefit strawberries, watermelons, citrus, avocados, lychees and many others. Research into the use of stingless bees for crop pollination in Australia is still in its very early stages, but these bees show great potential. Studies at the University of Western Sydney have shown these bees' excellent ability to work in confined areas such as glasshouses.
Stingless bees of Brazil
Brazil is home to several species of stingless bees belonging to meliponini tribe, with more than 300 species already identified and probably more yet to be discovered. They vary greatly in shape, size and habits, and 20 to 30 of these species have good potential as honey producers. Although they are still quite unknown by most people, there is an increasing number of beekeepers dedicated to these bees throughout the country. This activity has experienced significant growth since August 2004, when national laws were changed to allow native bee colonies to be freely marketed, which was previously forbidden in an unsuccessful attempt to protect these species. Nowadays the capture or destruction of existing colonies in nature is still forbidden, and only new colonies formed by the bees themselves in artificial traps can be collected from the wild. Most colonies marketed are artificially produced by authorized beekeepers, through division of already existing captive colonies.
Also, much practical and academic work is being done about the best ways of keeping such bees, multiply their colonies and explore the honey they produce. Among many others, species like jandaíra (Melipona subnitida) and true-uruçu (Melipona scutellaris) in the northeast of the country, mandaçaia (Melipona quadrifasciata) and yellow uruçu (Melipona rufiventris) in the south-southeast, tiúba or jupará (Melipona compressipes manaosensis) and straw-bee (Scaptotrigona polistycta) in the north and jataí (Tetragonisca angustula) throughout the country are increasingly kept by small, medium and large producers. Through cultivation of honey or selling the colonies themselves, keeping stingless bees is an increasingly profitable activity. A single colony of species like mandaçaia and true-uruçu can be divided up to 4 times a year, and each of the new colonies obtained this way can be sold by about US$100.
Although the colony sizes of most of these bees are much smaller than those of the European honey bee, the per bee productivity can be quite high, with colonies containing less than a thousand bees being able to produce up to 3 or 4 liters of honey every year. Probably the world champion in honey productivity, the manduri (Melipona Marginata) live in swarms with only about 300 individuals, but even so it can produce up to 3 litters of honey a year in the right conditions. One of the smallest among all bees in the genus Melipona, with length from 6 to 7 mm, it is being used in some countries like Japan and Germany as pollinators for glasshouses. But although they do not tend to attack if not molested, when they feel the nest is under menace their reaction is violent, with these tiny bees bitting so strong that can hurt people´s skin.
Species of the genus Scaptotrigona have very large colonies with up to 20.000 individuals and can produce from 8 to 12 liters of honey a year, but are somewhat aggressive and thus not popular among Brazilian meliponine beekeepers. Some larger breeders have more than 3,000 hives of the more tame but still highly productive species in the genus Melipona, like the tiúba, the true uruçu and the jandaíra, each with 3,000 or more bees, and can produce over 1.5 tons of honey per year (in large bee farms the availability of flowers limits the honey production per colony). Being considered more palatable by not being overly sweet, and also having medicinal properties more pronounced than honey from bees of the apis genus due to the presence of anti-microbial substances at a much higher level, the honey from stingless bees returns very high values in the market, even five or ten times greater than the common honey produced by European or Africanized bees. This makes production very interesting, even though a much larger number of beehives is required so that they can produce equivalent amounts of honey.
The honey from stingless bees has a lighter color and a higher water content (from 25% up to 35%) compared to the honey from the genus apis, whose honey consists of 20% or less of water. This contributes to its less cloying taste, but also causes it to spoil more easily. Thus, for marketing this honey needs to be processed through desiccation or pasteurization. In its natural state it should be kept under refrigeration.
Bees as "pets"
Due to the lack of a functional stinger and characteristic non-aggressive behavior of many Brazilian species of stingless bees, they can be kept without problems in densely populated environments such as cities, provided there are enough flowers at their disposal nearby. Some breeders (called meliponicultors) can produce honey even in apartments, up to the 12th floor.
Despite being in general fairly peaceful, with exception of a few species like the tubuna (Scaptotrigona bipuntacta), most Brazilian meliponini bees will usually react if their hives are molested, nipping with their jaws, entangling themselves in the hair, trying to enter in the ears or the nose and releasing propolis or even acid over their aggressors. But some species as the mandaçaia are extremely tame, not attacking humans even when their hives are opened for honey extraction or colony division. This, plus the fact it only form small colonies with 300 to 500 individuals, makes them particularly suitable for keeping at home as pets. One single rational beehive of mandaçaia can produce up to 4 liters of honey a year, making the species very attractive for home keepers, and being a fairly large bee with length up to 11mm it has a better body heat control, living in regions where temperature can drop a little lower than 0 °C. However, it is somewhat selective about which flowers to visit preferring the flora that occurs in their natural environment, and is thus difficult to be kept outside its region of origin, which is along the east coast of Brazil, from the state of Bahia to the south.
Other species like the tiúba and the true-uruçu are also very tame and highly productive. Their colonies have from 3.000 to 5.000 insects of the same size as the honey bees, and can produce up to 8 liters a year of honey. They can be easily kept at home, but will only survive in regions with warm climate, their larvae dying in temperatures lower than 12°C. The yellow uruçu, by another hand, can survive to temperatures lower than 0°C and their colonies, bearing about 3.500 individuals, can produce up to 6 liters of honey a year. But this species will react with powerful nipping if their nests are molested, and usually they are only kept by professional meliponicultors.
Another suitable species for keeping at home is the guaraipo (Melipona bicolor). It is also quite tame never attacking the beekeeper, their colonies have less than 600 individuals, they can withstand temperatures as low as -10 °C and each colony can produce over three liters of honey a year. One interesting thing about this species is that their colonies usually have more than one single queen at a time (usually two or three, but there can be up to five), a phenomenon called polygyne. But once very common, the guaraipo is now rather rare in nature, mainly due to the destruction of the forests where they could be found, in the south-southeast of Brazil.
Other groups of Brazilian stingless bees, belonging to the tribe trigonini, genera plebeia and leurotrigona, are also very tame and much smaller, one of them (Plebeia minima) reaching no more than 2.5 mm in length, and the lambe-olhos (licks-eyes, Leurotrigona muelleri) being even smaller, with no more than 1.5 mm. Many of these species are generally known as "mirim" (kid), and they can be kept in very small artificial hives thus being of interest for keepers who want them as pollinator agents in small glasshouses or just for the pleasure of having a "toy" bee colony at home. Being so tiny these species produce only a very small amount of honey, typically less than 500 ml a year, and therefore are not interesting for commercial honey production.
Belonging to the same Trigonini group, the jatai (Tetragonisca Angustula), the marmelada (Frieseomelitta Varia) and the moça-branca (Frieseomelitta Doederleini ) have intermediate sizes between those very small species and the European bee. They are very adaptable species, mainly the Jataí, and can be kept in many different regions and environments being quite common in most Brazilian cities. The jataí can bite when molested but its jaws are too weak and in practice they are harmless, while the marmelada and moça-branca usually deposit propolis on their aggressors. Producing up to 1,5 litters a year of a honey considered among the best from stingless bees, the jataí was one of the first species to be kept by home beekeepers. Their nest can be easely identified in trees or wall cavities by the wax pipe they build at the entrance, usually guarded by some soldier bees which have recently been found to be bigger and stronger than regular worker bees. The marmelada and moça-branca make a little less honey, but it is denser and sweeter than most of stingless bees, being considered very tasteful.
Mayan stingless bees of Central America
The stingless bees Melipona beecheii and M. yucatanica are the only native bees cultured to any degree in Central America. They were extensively cultured by the Maya for honey, and regarded as sacred. These bees are endangered due to massive deforestation, altered agricultural practices (especially insecticides), and changing beekeeping practices with the arrival of the Africanized honey bee, which produces much greater honey crops.
Native meliponines (Melipona beecheii being the favorite) have been kept by the lowland Maya for thousands of years. The traditional Mayan name for this bee is Xunan kab, literally meaning "royal lady". The bees were once the subject of religious ceremonies and were a symbol of the bee-god Ah-Muzen-Cab, who is known from the Madrid Codex.
The bees were, and still are, treated as pets. Families would have one or many log-hives hanging in and around their house. Although they are stingless, the bees do bite and can leave welts similar to a mosquito bite. The traditional way to gather bees, still favored among the locals, is find a wild hive; then the branch is cut around the hive to create a portable log, enclosing the colony. This log is then capped on both ends with another piece of wood or pottery and sealed with mud. This clever method keeps the melipine bees from mixing their brood, pollen, and honey in the same comb as the European bees. The brood is kept in the middle of the hive, and the honey is stored in vertical "pots" on the outer edges of the hive. A temporary, replaceable cap at the end of the log allows for easy access to the honey while doing minimal damage to the hive. However, inexperienced handlers can still do irreversible damage to a hive, causing the hive to swarm and abscond from the log. On the other hand, with proper maintenance, hives have been recorded as lasting over 80 years, being passed down through generations. In the archaeological record of Mesoamerica, stone discs have been found that are generally considered to be the caps of long-disintegrated logs that once housed the beehives.
Tulum, the site of an ancient Mayan city on the Caribbean coast 130 km south of Cancun, has a god depicted repeatedly all over the site. Upside down, he appears as a small figure over many doorways and entrances. One of the temples, the "Templo del Dios Descendente" or the Temple of the Descending God, stands just left of the central plaza. Speculation is that he may be the "Bee God", Ah Muzen Cab, as seen in the Madrid Codex. It is possible that this was a religious/trade center with emphasis on Xunan kab, the "royal lady".
Balché, a traditional Mesoamerican alcoholic beverage similar to mead, was made from fermented honey and the bark of the leguminous Balché tree (Lonchocarpus violaceus), hence its name. It was traditionally brewed in a canoe. The drink was known to have entheogenic properties, that is, to produce mystical experiences, and was consumed in medicinal and ritual practices. Beekeepers would place the nests near the psychoactive plant Turbina corymbosa and possibly near Balché trees, forcing the bees to use nectar from these plants to make their honey. Additionally, brewers would add extracts of the bark of the Balché tree to the honey mixture before fermentation. The resulting beverage is responsible for psychotropic effects when consumed, due to the ergoline compounds in the pollen of the T. corymbosathe, the Melipona nectar gathered from the Balché flowers, or the hallucinogenic compounds of the Balché tree bark.
Lost-wax casting, a common metalworking method typically found where the inhabitants keep bees, was also used by the Maya. The wax from Melipona is soft and easy to work, especially in the humid Mayan lowland. This allowed the Maya to create smaller works of art, jewelry, and other metalsmithing that would be difficult to forge. It also makes use of the leftovers from honey extraction. If the hive was damaged beyond repair, the whole of the comb could be used, thus using all of the hive. With experienced keepers, though, only the honey pot could be removed, the honey extracted, and the wax used for casting or other purposes.
The outlook for meliponines in Mesoamerica is grim. The number of active Melipona beekeepers is rapidly declining in favor of the more economical, non-indigenous Africanized Apis mellifera. The high honey yield, 100 kilograms or more annually, along with the ease of hive care and ability to create new hives from existing stock, commonly outweighs the negative consequences of "killer bee" hive maintenance. Furthermore, there are flora that the Africanized honey bees do not visit, such as those in the tomato family, and several forest trees and shrubs, which rely on the native stingless bees for pollination. There has already been a decline in populations of native flora in areas where stingless bees have been displaced by Africanized honey bees. An additional blow to the art of meliponine beekeeping is that many of the meliponine beekeepers are now elderly men and women, whose hives may not be cared for once they die. The hives are considered similar to an old family collection, to be parted out once the collector dies or to be buried in whole or part along with the beekeeper upon death. In fact, a survey of a once-popular area of the Mayan lowlands shows the rapid decline of beekeepers, down to around 70 in 2004 from thousands in the late 1980s. It is traditional in the Mayan lowlands that the hive itself or parts of the hive be buried along with the beekeeper to volar al cielo, "to fly to heaven". There are conservation efforts underway in several parts of Mesoamerica.
Stingless bee species that produce honey
- Austroplebeia spp.
- Cephalotrigona spp.
- C. capitata
- Frieseomelitta spp.
- Partamona spp.
- Scaptotrigona spp.
- Schwarziana spp.
- Tetragona spp.
- Tetragonisca spp.
- Trigona spp.
- Melipona spp.
- Meliponula spp.
- Michener, C D. The bees of the World. Johns Hopkins University Press, 972 pp.
- Silveira, F A; Melo, G A R; Almeida, E A B. 2002. Abelhas Brasileiras: Sistemática e Identificação. Fernando A. Silveira, 253 pp.
- Roubik, D W. 1989. Ecology and Natural History of Tropical Bees. Cambridge Tropical Biology Series, 528 pp.
- Cortopassi-Laurino, M C; Imperatriz-Fonseca, V L; Roubik, D W; Dollin, A; Heard, T; Aguilar, I; Venturieri, G C; Eardley, C; Nogueira-Neto, P. 2006. "Global meliponiculture: challenges and opportunities". Apidologie 37: 275–292.
- Venturieri, G C; Raiol, V F O; Pareira, C A B 2003. "Avaliação da introfução da criação racional de Melipona fasciculata (Apidae: Meliponina), entre os agricultores familiares de Bragança - PA, Brasil". Biota Neotropica 3(2): 1–7.
- Koch, H. 2010. "Combining morphology and DNA barcoding resolves the taxonomy of Western Malagasy Liotrigona Moure", 1961. African Invertebrates 51 (2): 413–421.PDF fulltext
- Souza, R C S; Yuyama, L K O; Aguiar, J P L; Oliveira, F P M. 2004. "Valor nutricional do mel e pólen de abelhas sem ferrão da região amazônica". Acta Amazonica 34(2): 333–336.
- Ribeiro, M F. 2002. "Does the queen of Plebeia remota ( Hymenoptera , Apidae , Meliponini ) stimulate her workers to start brood cell construction after winter?" Insectes Sociaux 49: 38–40.
- Alves, D A; Imperatriz-Fonseca, V L; Santos-Filho, P S. 2009. "Production of workers, queens and males in Plebeia remota colonies (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Meliponini), a stingless bee with reproductive diapause". Genetics and Molecular Research 8(2): 672–683.
- Roubik, D W. 2006. "Stingless bee nesting biology". Apidologie 37: 124–143.
- Venturieri, G C. 2004. "Meliponicultura: Criação de Abelhas Indígenas Sem Ferrão". Comunicado Técnico Embrapa Amazônia Oriental 118: 1–4.
- Contrera, F A L; Venturieri, G C. 2008. "Vantagens e Limitações do Uso de Abrigos Individuais e Comunitários para a Abelha Indígena sem Ferrão Uruçu-Amarela (Melipona flavolineata)". Comunicado Técnico Embrapa Amazônia Oriental 211: 1–6.
- Villanueva-G, R; Roubik, D W; Colli-Ucán, W. 2005. "Extinction of Melipona beecheii and traditional beekeeping in the Yucatán peninsula". Bee World 86: 35–41.
- Kerr, W E. 1950. "Genetic determination of castes in the genus Melipona". Genetics 35: 143–152.
- Wenseleers, T., F. L. W. Ratnieks, M. de F. Ribeiro, D. de A. Alves & V. Imperatriz-Fonseca. (2005) "Working-class royalty: bees beat the caste system". Biol. Lett. 1(2): 125–8
- Wendy Pyper (May 8, 2003). "Stingless bee rescue". ABC Science.
- "New Greenhouse Pollination Study With Trigona". Aussie Bee Bulletin (10). May 1999. "Pablo Occhiuzzi of the University of Western Sydney is studying the greenhouse pollination of capsicum with Trigona carbonaria."
- Ott, Jonathan (1998). "The Delphic bee: Bees and toxic honeys as pointers to psychoactive and other medicinal plants". Economic Botany 52 (3): 260–266. doi:10.1007/BF02862143.
- A comprehensive conservation guide can be found in the June 2005 issue of Bee World.